Skip to main content

Mishimoto Cooling Upgrade Order

As the car had done ~94k miles I thought it would be time to refresh the cooling system as part of the build project. It also gave me an opportunity to remove the viscous clutch fan, as I have never liked these. This is similar to my dislike for sleeving engines that aren't low-revving V8's, I have no science to support why I don't like them, I just don't.

 My main driver here was to upgrade to something better than stock with increased reliability. As with my other parts decisions I also wanted to stick to something that for the most part came as a ready to install kit specifically for the E46 M3.

 Fortunately (or unfortunately) there was a lot of options to chose from when it came to cooling upgrade for the E46 M3. I compiled a list of some of the options I reviewed / considered:


I am sure there is more options out there but at the time of writing this these were the only ones that I found and reviewed / considered.

Now during my review it became clear that the consensus was that if you were going to depart from a true OEM refresh then the Zionsville radiator was the best option. Unfortunately it was also the most expensive, and whilst it came with the option to be paired with a shroud and fan, it did not have an accompanying oil cooler. This is despite the fact that it was priced at a similar range as the other companies with their oil cooler included.

In general I found the reviews and feedback for the Fluidyne, C&R and CSF products to all be very similar. Comparable prices, comparable offerings and similar fitment. They all offered radiators and oil coolers, but did not have a fan shroud / fan package that I found at the time. Now had it not been for the development I will discuss next I would have investigated these brands further to distinguish between them and potentially make a purchase.
Instead I moved on to review Mishimoto's offering. This caught my eye very quickly for no other reason than the fact they have everything ready to go; radiator, fan, fan shroud, wiring and oil cooler. Investigating further I found that Mishimoto seemed to be generally well regarded by anyone who bothered to try them over at M3Cutters but extremely polarising and derided by many over at M3Forum. It turns out that there was some serious design flaws in the initial radiator offered which made them a lot of enemies, despite the fact they had subsequently revised the design to address the issues.

The oil cooler on the other hand seemed to be liked by most who had used it and the fan shroud and fan were used widely by people who even decided to go with another brands radiator.

With this in mind I started looking at prices and managed to find an Australian distributor of Mishimoto, Car Mods Australia. When enquiring through them I was able to get them to offer me a package price (ordering the radiator, fan shroud, oil cooler and radiator hoses) which I could not match when pricing up the other company offerings (CSF, C&R, Fluidyne). Admittedly this had a lot to do with shipping and GST on these products after import as I could not find an Australia distributor for them.

 Given the unbeatable price I managed to get and reasonable reviews from the community. Admittedly not the greatest reviews but it is at least considered an upgrade from OEM now with the redesigned Radiator. Which makes it worthwhile when you consider that price I got them for was cheaper than OEM replacements so I decided to go ahead with a purchase.




 

Labels

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

///M Clubsport Door Sills Search

Whilst starting the preparation and install for my Karbonius CSL Carbon Fibre Roof I started thinking about the final overall style of the car again. It particularly came to the front of my mind when a friend, who was working with me on the roof install, asked what the deal with the CS badge on the boot was. I realised tat whilst that choice had made sense to me it may not really land with others who are unfamiliar with BMWs and understand the history of the CS badging or the idea of what the Clubsport moniker encapsulates. From previous research and investigations into Clubsport branding from BMW that I could use to keep the style I knew of the somewhat rare E46 330i Clubsport so i thought I should take another look to see if there was anything from that that might help pull the theme together at all. It was at that point that I came across the ///M Clubsport door sills that are used on the  E46 330i Clubsport.  They struck me as perfect to help tie the theme together. They a...
Post a Comment
Read more

Syncro Design Works RTAB Install

Now it was time to get around to trying to install my new Syncro Design Works RTAB's. As I had not borrowed the RTAB tool from Syncro Design Works I was going to have to try figure this out on my own. At first I attempted to rig up a press on the outer ring of the RTAB using my 3-jaw puller which was more complicated than you would think. This did work quite effectively but annoyingly there wasn't much space in the jaws for how deep the press was so I had to use a somewhat flimsy grease cap to try push on the outer ring. This worked for about half the press then it completely crushed itself so I aborted before any pressure was applied to the bearing's inner race. Unfortunately I didn't manage to snap any pictures during this operation so all I have is this photo of where I had to stop: Luckily I have a mate who has a bearing press anyway so I wasn't completely out of options. This was an easy option for me as my Rear Trailing Arm was out of the car as part ...
Post a Comment
Read more

///M3 CS (ClubSport) Badging

As part of the overall theme of my car build I have wanted to set my car apart from other less modified or standard E46 M3s whilst staying true to a BMW styling. I wanted the car to look like it could have come off the factory floor as a BMW option package and drive well on the street, whilst also tearing up on the track. This is part of why for most of my build I have referred to it as a Clubsport build and this gave me the idea to try capture that naming and apply it to the theme of the car. There was never officially a BMW E46 M3 Clubsport as the BMW E46 M3 CS that Europe got was actually a Coupe Sport and obviously the CSL was the pinnacle model which as discussed previously I cannot really replicate from. So I started thinking about badging and labeling and was reminded of some of the M3Forum guys with Supercharged M3s who use a CSL badge but switch it around to give themselves a ///M3 sc which I always thought was kind of cool and set them apart without being too tacky. The use o...
Post a Comment
Read more